A new report seeks to compare ERP software from two vendor giants, attempting to reveal the relative strengths and weaknesses of Oracle and SAP. Titled “Clash of the Titans: SAP vs. Oracle,” the analysis provides a run-down of the functionality, products, and technologies offered by each vendor, and enumerates which is the best ERP software for customers. In case you’re already thinking the report might issue partial judgments, the study was conducted and published by the Panorama Consulting Group, an independent ERP consulting firm. Panorama Consulting Group claims they are in no way affiliated with the two companies in the report, or any other software vendor, for that matter.
“SAP and Oracle are the industry’s leading ERP vendors for good reasons,” Panorama PR Representative Eric Kimberling said. “However, as with any comparison of ERP Software solutions, each has its strengths, weaknesses, and trade-offs depending on a company’s unique business requirements. Potential ERP solutions should be objectively compared against these individual organizational needs as part of an effective ERP software selection process.”
Though the full report is too detailed to explain fully, here’s a quick rundown of the process and products of the analysis. The comparison data on SAP and Oracle was obtained by appraising each vendor’s market share, user satisfaction, payback period, project cost, implementation duration, and benefits realization. While not comprehensive, this covers most of the concerns of a prospective customer. Under those metrics, the following products were thrown into the fray: Oracle’s e-Business Suite, JD Edwards EnterpriseOne, and PeopleSoft Enterprise, and SAP’s Business Suite, Business All-in-One, and Business One. The report also included the software as a service (SaaS) model comparisons of Oracle’s On-Demand and SAP’s ByDesign.
While discussing the companies’ current products is helpful, no one wants to build a company on a vendor with a shaky infrastructure or poor future prospects. In order to provide a completely accurate snapshot of the viability of both companies, the report also analyses Oracle’s and SAP’s technology infrastructure and future roadmap. The intangibles factored into the judgment don’t stop there, either. The report also provides an appraisal of each vendor’s functional strengths as well as pulling data from existing clients of each company, distilling that data into an average functional score for the company based on satisfaction ratings.
This is, of course, a lot of information to absorb. While it’s tempting to peruse the report results and declare a clear winner, the reality is that there won’t be a vendor that excels another in every area. When it comes to an ERP implementation, you must identify the unique needs of your own business. Do you need an extremely quick implementation or is it more vital to save money? After identifying your particular priorities, it is much easier to choose a vendor that matches those needs. Reports like this are ideal for helping in that situation, though hopefully broader reports will come along in the future. Reports that compare Microsoft Dynamics GP to SAP or to Oracle would provide even more information for the prospective ERP implementation. Download the complete report: “Clash of the Titans: An Independent Comparison of SAP vs. Oracle” (registration required).
Looking for a way to learn more about Micosoft Dynamics ERP products and do your own comparison? Visit www.erpsoftwareblog.com
One thing I do not like is the fact you are detail oriented which is fine except many detail style people are obnoxious. I would say something to counter that such as people enjoy working with me.
Posted by: Marcella Hughes | 09/19/2011 at 04:49 AM
no one wants to build a company on a vendor with a shaky infrastructure or poor future prospects. In order to provide a completely accurate snapshot of the viability of both companies, the report also analyses Oracle’s and SAP’s technology infrastructure and future roadmap. The intangibles factored into the judgment don’t stop there, either. The report also provides an appraisal of each vendor’s functional strengths as well as pulling data from existing clients of each company, distilling that data into an average functional score for the company based on satisfaction ratings.
Posted by: wool-boots.com | 10/10/2011 at 10:56 PM
Titled “Clash of the Titans: SAP vs. Oracle,” the analysis provides a run-down of the functionality, products, and technologies offered by each vendor, and enumerates which is the best ERP software for customers. In case you’re already thinking the report might issue partial judgments, the study was conducted and published by the Panorama Consulting Group, an independent ERP consulting firm. Panorama Consulting Group claims they are in no way affiliated with the two companies in the report, or any other software vendor, for that matter.
Posted by: boots clearance | 10/10/2011 at 10:59 PM
Hey, baby! I agree with the idea, perhaps our peers, this is a consensus! I want to use this article, believe that you will agree to me!
Posted by: Prada Outlet | 11/24/2011 at 09:54 PM
I cannot wait to read more of this article,you gave me some new ideas. Thank Auther for having teached me something, I have learnt from you something. It is so unbelievble. Very good very impressive performance.
Posted by: Prada Outlet | 12/01/2011 at 07:33 PM
http://www.coatinstock.com
Posted by: air jordan for sale | 12/26/2011 at 01:07 AM
JPOPLMAGZS ugg boots FLPQABMUEL http://blog.bodybuilding.com/quincymays37/2011/12/19/be_adequate_your_own_demand/
Posted by: MyncTrotnenny | 12/30/2011 at 01:07 AM
FATYCMHAYH louis vuitton replica HGYNURYIQS http://just-my-opinion.com/general/replica-louis-vuitton-very-long.html
Posted by: allexjese | 02/06/2012 at 01:01 AM
YES! I finally found this web page! I’ve been looking just for this article for so long!!
Posted by: nike running shoes sale | 02/09/2012 at 12:41 AM